

Something is simmering in Guelph, and it's not just what's happening in the kitchens. Guelph’s culinary landscape is evolving into something far more exciting than one might expect from a city of this size. An increasingly ambitious community of restaurateurs is raising the stakes, challenging expectations and bringing a fresh sense of style to the table. Yet this is not at the expense of conviviality—the simple pleasure of gathering around a table remains at the heart of Buon Gusto Restaurant, whose substantial renovation and recent reopening—with a refreshed dining room, expanded kitchen and enhanced private dining facilities—reflect a commitment to sophistication without pretension.
We enter the bright, airy and inviting dining room of Buon Gusto, which strikes the right balance between rustic charm and urban hipness. Stone walls and warm wood panelling lend an earthy character to the otherwise contemporary space, while exposed piping overhead introduces an industrial edge. The marble-topped bar adds a touch of elegance, and the open kitchen brings the culinary action into the dining room. It is both polished and approachable, with just enough edge to keep things interesting.
Seated near the open kitchen, we watch as dishes are assembled and whisked away like clockwork. At its heart is a wood-burning oven imported from Tuscany, where the traditions of Italian cooking meet the energy of a contemporary dining room.
Flavours abound as comfort food wafts past our table, from charred octopus to crispy pork belly. Our Caprese, an homage to the flag of Italy, is a dish of thick heirloom tomatoes with creamy fior di latte and slightly crisped-basil leaves for contrasting texture. Enlivened by dollops of herbaceous freshly-made pesto, a sprinkling of toasted pine nuts, and a drizzle of olive oil and balsamic reduction, the dish harmonizes to sing all the right notes. But Buon Gusto is known for their pizzas and pastas. The menu showcases tempting choices, and even innovative feature-pizzas, including one with balsamic-soaked coronation grapes, mascarpone and rosemary, or another totally unique feature made with squid ink-dyed pizza dough, Béchamel sauce, baccala, pancetta, balsamic onions, purple potatoes and parsley.
We choose the Margherita—a celebration of simplicity. There’s no reinventing the wheel. It’s a flavour-forward assemblage of the bright acidity of the tomatoes, the milky richness of mozzarella, and the fragrance of basil sealed with a kiss of olive oil that proves less really is amore. What stands out most is the crust. The kitchen lets the dough ferment for two days for a delicious thin crust that doesn’t flop and a blistered cornicione of lip-smacking goodness that I dare not leave one crumb behind.
The pasta selection is a survey of the Italy’s culinary landscape from Bolognese to Genovese. Linguine Pescatore is chock full of seafood. The kitchen does not skimp on the scampi. Shrimp, calamari, mussels, clams and cod are sautéed in white wine, entwined in pasta imported directly from Italy, and lavished in a rich tomato sauce with a gentle kick of peperoncino.
Too-tempting-to-resist is the Black Truffle Risotto, blended with a forest of mushrooms. A hefty bowl of creamy arborio rice, accented with white wine and thyme is replete with porcini, cremini, honey and oyster mushrooms that elicit an earthy medley of silky textures. While a little heavy-handed with the salt, the combination of shaved black truffle and Grana Padano elevates the dish with savoury and umami notes for a nourishing velvety confluence that warms us on a cold night.
We can’t help noticing what other tables have ordered. The Lasagna looks perfect in its decadent presentation. Chicken Cacciatore is a generous bronzed crisp chicken resting on a vibrant rustic tomato stew, and I’m imagining it’s pairing with a Chianti. Next time. For now, we select a beautiful bone-in Ontario veal chop. Ten ounces of succulent tender veal seared to a smoky char from the grill is lacquered with a generous tumble of plump blueberries glistening in a rich, deep-purple reduction. The sweet and tart notes of the berry jus lend a dual complement to the delicate flavour of the meat. The thick chop sits on a velvety cushion of smooth mashed sweet potato, and crisp asparagus spears.
We're certainly not going to leave here hungry, but looking at this menu we have already mapped out another colourful variety of choices for our next visit.
Buon Gusto feels like the intersection between neighbourhood hub and upscale dining. The congenial vibe is not sacrificed by the push to refinement. Service is both attentive and relaxed, so we feel comfortably at home.
Located within the cornucopia of Guelph’s farm country, Buon Gusto makes fresh, local ingredients a cornerstone of its menu. Nearly everything is made in-house, including daily handmade pastas and pizza dough. Other ingredients stay true to the source of Italian cuisine. Wine enthusiasts and appassionati di vino gravitate to the wine selection from Buon Gusto’s carefully curated wine cellar for pairings to enliven each dish.
Parting can be such sweet sorrow, unless it’s by way of affogato. Here, Buon Gusto has partnered with local gourmet cookie shop, Milk & Co, to zhuzh up their affogato by ladling one lush scoop of vanilla gelato into a thick chocolate chip cookie cup before enrobing it in an espresso pour-over. A sweet finale to a fulfilling Italian affair.
Buon Gusto Restaurant, 69 Wyndham St N, Guelph, 519-265-8766